I Want Your Love (2012) __top__ -

This is not erotic spectacle for a voyeur; it is behavioral realism. The camera doesn’t leer—it observes. By refusing to cut away or simulate, Mathews achieves the opposite of titillation: he normalizes the act. In doing so, he reveals how sex functions as conversation, as comfort, and sometimes as a desperate placeholder for words that won’t come. Strip away the explicit content, and I Want Your Love is one of the saddest films of its decade. San Francisco—post-Prop 8, post-gentrification, pre-marriage equality—is shot as a city of soft, gray light and empty streets. The Castro is not a party; it is a backdrop for economic anxiety and emotional drift.

In one devastating, quiet scene, Jesse and Jason lie on a mattress, fully clothed, talking about nothing. The camera holds. No sex. No drama. Just two people who know they will miss each other. It is the most intimate moment in the film. I Want Your Love belongs to a specific subgenre of queer cinema: the elegy for pre-gentrification, pre-Internet gay domesticity. Like Andrew Haigh’s Weekend (2011) or Ira Sachs’ Keep the Lights On (2012), it captures a moment when gay identity was still defined by physical space—the house party, the shared bed, the dive bar. Jesse’s impending move to the Midwest feels less like a geographic shift than an erasure of self.

I Want Your Love is not a film about sex. It is a film about the space between sex—the moments after, the days before, and the love that lingers in the silence when no one is performing. That is far more uncomfortable, and far more beautiful, than any explicit act. i want your love (2012)

Mathews, who is gay, casts non-professional actors playing versions of themselves (Metzger and McDonald share screenwriting credit). This blurs autobiography into fiction, giving the film the texture of a home movie shot through with existential dread. These aren’t characters; they are people caught mid-life, unaware they are being watched. Upon release, I Want Your Love was banned or censored in several countries (including, briefly, New Zealand). It played festivals alongside shouts of "art" and "obscenity." A decade later, those debates feel tired. In a streaming era where queer intimacy is often sanitized for mass consumption or exaggerated for prestige melodrama, Mathews’ film stands as a stubborn artifact of honesty.

It endures because it refuses to explain itself. It does not apologize for the male body, nor does it romanticize it. It shows gay men as they are: horny, lonely, loyal, scared, and desperately trying to touch something real before it slips away. This is not erotic spectacle for a voyeur;

Jesse is a protagonist defined by inaction. He loves his friends, but he is leaving them. He still desires Fer, but the relationship has curdled into a pattern of care without commitment. The film’s title becomes ironic: I Want Your Love is a plea, not a statement of possession. It is the ache of wanting something you already have but cannot keep.

Born from a 2010 short of the same name, Mathews’ feature expands the narrative of Jesse (Jesse Metzger), a gay man in his early thirties living in San Francisco. He is facing a quiet crisis: his financial situation forces him to move back to the Midwest, away from the chosen family and lovers who have defined his adult life. Over the course of a long, languid goodbye, he navigates lingering feelings for his ex, Fer (Matthew F. Rios), and a hesitant, undefined bond with his best friend, Jason (Keith McDonald). The first thing any discussion of I Want Your Love must address is its sexual frankness. The film contains unsimulated sex acts, most famously a prolonged, three-way scene between Jesse, Fer, and another man. But to label it "pornography" is to misunderstand its grammar. Where porn seeks climax (both narrative and physical), Mathews seeks duration. The sex is awkward, tender, logistical, and sometimes funny. There is negotiation ("Is this okay?"), there is fumbling, and there is the quiet, unglamorous reality of bodies in motion. In doing so, he reveals how sex functions

Watch it not for what it shows, but for what it holds. It holds time. And time, as Jesse learns, is the only thing we cannot fake.